Karyn quickly put the stone back in it's box and closed it, but didn't move to give it back to Jon.
Jon was shocked and confused, why would she need to wish for him to be honest, didn't she trust him? He started to ask her. "Why..."
Karyn was incredibly nervous about the next part, she wanted Jon to give her his real feelings and not try to hide anything to spare her feelings. As he started speaking she interrupted with "Do you think I look more attractive with the new hair and boobs?"
Jon was even more surprised by that question, but before he could process the feeling his mouth was moving and he was answering her.
"No to the hair, I liked your proper hair a lot, it suits you as a person and I like red hair." He tried to stop talking before the next part, but he couldn't, the words came out anyway. "Yes I think you are more attractive with the bigger boobs."
Embarrassment was all over Jon's face, and reflected in his body language. Now he understood why she wished for him to be honest, but why 5 questions? He was avoiding making eye contact out of embarrassment.
Karyn for her part was doing her best to maintain a poker face, she had somewhat expected this answer. The next question though was the one that scared her.
"Do you have romantic feelings towards me?"
Jon was even more stunned by this question, and the answer that came out of his mouth surprised him further. "Yes. Wait no, what, I don't!"
"Apparently you can't even say something wrong you consciously don't know is wrong... interesting." Karyn said
"But..." Jon, was reeling, he could feel his cheeks burning as he blushed, but Karyn was right, he must have actual feelings for her... even if he had been convincing himself he didn't.
Karyn maintained her poker face, Jon couldn't tell at all if this was the answer she wanted to hear or not.
"Why... Why'd you ask that?" Jon stuttered.
"Suspicion. I did a lot of thinking last night. Why didn't you ever bring up your feelings?"
Jon had no idea what he was about to say, and in fact he was as interested as Karyn in finding out. "I was afraid I would lose our current relationship and suppressed my feelings, I've had feelings for you for years." Jon was beyond embarrassment at this point, he was surprised at the answer he gave, but he couldn't deny it was true, and acknowledging it and no longer able to hide the feelings from himself he found himself hoping that these were the answers Karyn was hoping to hear, that the feelings run both ways, terrified that they don't.
"Would you be sad if we managed to get my hair and boobs back to the way they were?"
Jon was surprised by this question, and now that he wasn't trying to suppress his feelings for Karyn as hard, he knew the answer he was about to give and wished he could lie, but he couldn't, nor could he stop himself from speaking.
"The hair no, I'd actually be thrilled, both happy for you getting what I assume you want and because I like your old look better anyway. The boobs, yes..." he tried to force himself to at least down play this part, but he couldn't, as he kept talking he could feel the blush returning, "I like them, and unlike your hair, with the way you dress, they still fit with your look. It kind of enhances the 'Tomboy' cuteness since they're so obviously feminine, but mostly hidden by how you usually dress. That is they fit in with my image of you, but I also like big boobs and since I like you I would like them to stay."
The hold of the wish on him released, and finally he could speak freely again. "Oh, uhm I'm... I... that is... I still want to help you get back to normal though..."
Karyn let a smile through her poker face for a moment. "Thanks, I didn't doubt that." She paused, let the smile stay on her face and asked her last question, "Would you be willing try dating me?"
Jon felt a rush of emotions at that question, he couldn't identify all of them as they washed over him, and the wish forced him to say simply "Yes. I would like that a lot."
"Well I guess that it's it then, wish done, and well since you're willing we're now dating. Jon-boyfriend!" She lunged and hugged him as she said the last part.
Jon was still emotionally reeling, and nearly fell over as she had a fair bit of momentum still when she reached him. He could feel her wish enhanced boobs pressing against him and for the first time he got a sense of how big they actually are... and felt his body responding. It took him several seconds to pull himself together enough to hug her back, and then she kissed him, full on the lips... and again he was overcome, but he did manage to kiss back.
She broke the kiss and stepped back, now having turned bright red herself. "God Jon it was so hard to maintain composure through all those questions."
"I... bet it was... so you had feelings for me too?"
"I... yeah, though I was doing the same as you... but last night, I was thinking about how you looked when my boobs got bigger, and it made me think of all kinds of other times... and I sort of got suspicious that you had a crush on me... and when that happened I realized... I liked you..."
"Huh." Jon was unsure how to feel. "I... what would you have asked if I had said something different?"
"Dunno, I wouldn't have asked if you would be sad about my boobs though."
"Why did you ask that? I sure wish I could have not answered."
"Oh do you? Really I wanted to know. I certainly wouldn't expect you to have given that answer without wishing honesty on to you!"
He thought for a moment, "Yeah. I... well I can't really help it, can I?"
"I guess, not but I don't really get it."
"What there's nothing about my body you think would look better different? Like what if I got all fit and had muscles, and then went back to now."
"Naw... I like you as you are. Your muscles are obvious enough, I can see them on your arms."
"Huh"
"I do kinda wish I did understand why you like these things so much", she said gesturing to her chest
Jon tensed up, his face moved in obvious terror.
"Relax Jon-boyfriend, I put it back in it's box," Karyn held up the closed box, "see. No more careless wishing for me. I've learned that lesson. Though... I guess..."
"I'm not sure I like where this is going..."
"Aww don't be such a stick, I could use the stone to get a better understanding of you... I mean I have often wondered what's up with how boys act about boobs."
"What are you thinking..." Jon said, hesitantly.
"Well...", now it was Karyn's turn to be embarrassed, "I could wish that you had big boobs, for say two days and that for those same two days I would find big boobs on men as attractive as you find them on women. Or something like that."
"I... I'm not sure about that." Jon wasn't super excited about the idea of having boobs himself... but Karyn having an understanding of what it's like... that wasn't such a bad thing...
Karyn was starting to think... it might be interesting! Just for two days, to get an idea of something so foreign to her and outside her experience. Something that she couldn't have ever experienced without the power of the stone. She brought to bear all her Jon convincing techniques. She could see the opening, the idea that she would be understanding. "C'mon, it'll be interesting and educational for us both, you'll be able to sympathize when I complain about them, I'll be able to understand if you get distracted and look at mine once in a while! Maybe since we are dating we can make out for the first time while we both have them! It can feel nice to have them touched you know!"
"I..." Jon digested what she was saying, the idea of her feeling him up... felt weird as hell in his head, but at the same time... maybe it would be fun? "I guess... two days? How big?"
"Hmmm. I was thinking we just say 'big' and let the wish pick. I didn't really choose how big mine are... I'm actually pretty sure they're bigger than Sarah's, they aren't a straight copy of hers for sure."
"Bigger? Really?" Jon tried to picture Karyn without her shirt, but with boobs bigger than Sarah... "I never would have guessed. I can't even picture it."
"Yes, really, I suppose you're not the only one who'd never think it, no one really treated me any different today at school... I didn't notice many more looks than normal." The longer the conversation went on, the more Karyn was interested in this idea of hers, "How about this... I'm excited that we're together now... and I kinda want to do something to reinforce that idea in my head, but... well I want this wish too, so if we do the boobs thing we also wish to be left alone for an hour and we make out... and I'll take my shirt and bra off for you."
Jon was floored, and it took several seconds for him to fully register what she was saying, part of him that he had been ignoring had wanted that for years... and now he couldn't ignore it.
Karyn was waiting nervously for him to respond, "I... I mean that isn't to say I wouldn't do anything if you don't want to try the wish thing... I honestly still want to... but well I'll leave my shirt on for... a little while." She was turning red as she spoke.
"I... OK, you've convinced me."
"Oh is that all, I just have to promise to show you my boobs, the power of boobs compels you!" She said with wry joking tone.
Jon was embarrassed at her "I... mean a little bit... but mostly it's how much you obviously want to, and besides it means you'll fully understand the power of boobs, and I will be full armed and operational on that front!"
"Heh front!" Karyn giggled, "Maybe we should do a week... just so that it'll include a weekend?" She looked hopeful at Jon. "It's not much of a difference... and I kinda want to get to spend at least a full day with you while you have them..."
"I... yeah, OK, if I'm doing this you're right not much difference between two days and a week in the grand scheme of things..."
"OK let's work out exactly what we're wishing."
"OK, how about 'for the next week; Karyn finds boobs on men physically attractive in a similar way to the way that men find them attractive on women, and she prefers them to be big' as the wish that affects you and just 'for the next week Jon has big boobs' as the one affecting me?"
"I sounds good to me. I think that should result in me having an experience close enough to what a normal guy feels about a girl." She took out the stone,again holding it tight in her hand. "I wish that for the next hour and a half Jon's parents and siblings would leave us alone and not hear any sounds we make in this room, and not notice that we have the door shut.", there was a flash, but nothing seemed to have changed.
Karyn got up and closed Jon's bedroom door. "That should give us enough privacy to have some fun together. I wish that for the next week; I will find boobs on men physically attractive in a similar way to the way that men find them attractive on women, and I prefer them to be big." The stone flashed again, and this time she felt something strange in her head, and looking at Jon he... seemed to be less attractive... missing something... it felt very weird. She tried imaging him with boobs, mentally growing them from flat... as the got bigger they looked better... to a point, it felt very weird to feel this way. "Woah... that's... weird."
"Oh? How?"
"I... don't think I can explain... I'm going to keep going and get this thing back in it's box ASAP. I wish that for the next week Jon has nice big boobs, with feminine nipples and that they are at least as sensitive as mine." As she finished speaking she got ready to put the stone away.
"Hey that wasn't..."
Jon was interrupted by the stone's flash and Karyn had to look away from him. As it was flashing she put it back in it's box, and snapped it shut, she wanted it out of her hands the moment she was done with it. When she looked back her eyes went straight to his chest.
Jon's eyes closed, and then he felt it, the weight of his new breasts, they felt heavy, he felt the tightness of the band of a bra around his chest, the straps on his shoulders, his shirt was now tight across his chest, he opened his eyes and looked down.
They were huge, more than he could cover with one hand, obviously bigger than grapefruits or softballs, but decidedly smaller than say a volleyball.
Karyn couldn't take her eyes off them, they were stunning, even with Jon's shirt only showing some of the way they curved back towards his body, draping off them hiding his torso, she could tell they had a very nice shape, she didn't really know exactly what a nice shape for them was... but Jon's were. The way the shirt rippled and stretched to bridge the space between them, the slight jiggle when he moved... all of it was stunning to her now.
They both sat in silence for a few minutes before Jon said. "So..."
Karyn didn't seem to hear him.
"Hey, Karyn! Earth to Karyn!"
"Huh?"
"I'm up here Karyn"
She turned bright red, and even as she did, she felt her eyes drifting back to his chest. "Sorry!"
Jon laughed. "It's OK... but... what do we..."
"Oh! That!" Karyn was feeling herself get turned on just looking at Jon's boobs with his shirt on... what would it be like if they were just out... "I guess I did promise some fun, didn't I? Will you... show me everything I show you?"
