"No, no more, Jon, please!" Karyn cried.
"It's too late to ask for mercy, you have had this punishment coming for a long time," Jon said coldly, but still in her high girl voice.
"Do I really deserve this?" Karyn objected.
"Every bit of it," Jon said. "No remorse. You should have known what you were getting into."
"But you have no idea, how much, this, nyaaaa!!" Karyn cried out, as Jon squeezed Karyn's new furry back paws with her own front paws, and stroked Karyn's long black-furred tail with her hands, all down its length to its white fluffy tip. Jon had made all these parts not merely ticklish, but erogenous.
"Oh my," Jon said, as Karyn uncontrollably came, making a white-yellow geyser into the air, as her body convulsed and her back arched backwards, her tail puffing up. Jon squeezed Karyn's paw-toes some more and the geyser gushed again, and then stimulated Karyn's various places for another 30 seconds before Karyn's body finally calmed down. "Tell me Karyn, what did you think of that? How did you like being forced to come after just getting your back paws squeezed and your toes tickled and your tail stroked?"
"That," Karyn gasped, "was, just, more, probably more, than the, human brain, is supposed to feel."
"And you deserved every bit of it. My special kitty girl."
"Meow," Karyn said. "I love you."
"But was it actually good?" Jon asked.
Karyn took a few more breaths. "Of course it was good. What kind, of a question was that. Damn it, Jon, that was so good, I don't know if I can even be satisfied with normal sex again."
"Are you happy? Do you like your new body?" Jon asked, concerned that she had gone too far.
"Yeah," she admitted. "Of course, how could I possibly not," she said, cuddling her head against Jon's shoulder and purring as they both lay on their backs on her bed, stroking Jon's breasts with two front paws, reaching around her with a third arm, and scritching Jon's ears with the fourth, while their long fluffy tails entwined. "So much, I don't know how I can stand the idea of changing back."
"When do your parents get back?" Jon asked back, purring herself.
"I don't know. They didn't give me an itinerary. It could be any time. Jon, I was thinking, maybe you could put some sort of, hypnotizing power, into our paws, so that we can stay like this, without other people finding it strange? I don't want to change back. I don't want to only be able to be like this in private with you."
"Hmmm. I'll make it so the hypnosis power doesn't work on us, you know," Jon said suspiciously.
"Of course. Jon do you still not trust me?" Karyn protested, hurt.
"No, I trust you. In fact, it's about time I give you back your power. Hold out your paws kitten," Jon asked lovingly.
Karyn held them forward, and Jon pulled them off and made them disappear into nothing, leaving behind her human hands. Karyn wasn't bolting or racing to get the upper hand on Jon again. There was no need for retribution for this after all.
"All right. So here's what I'm going to try to do now Karyn. I need to concentrate. I'm going to give you back your kitty paws, just as they just were," she started.
"Good," Karyn said with a smile.
"But, this time rather than restraining your power, they will have the power to pull out new body parts, out of nowhere, and the power to attach them or remove them from yourself or others with only you being able to remove the parts you put in, and the power to hypnotize anyone else but me in any way you want. But that's a complicated order, so please be quiet so I can concentrate on all that.
Karyn was silent, while Jon pondered and eventually procured four black-furred kitty paws. Karyn happily held forward each hand as Jon put them on carefully. Then Karyn did something a little surprising to Jon. She took off her own breasts, and then attempted to and failed to remove her lower pair of arms.
“Jon, I’m tired of being able to accidentally remove my own breasts. I want you to give me a good pair of tits, so that I can’t take them off myself. It looks like I can’t take off my lower arms, that’s good, because I want to keep them too, I’m guessing because by removing them, I would also be removing the paws which you put into them and only you can take them off.”
“How big?” Jon asked.
“Double D size, just like what I took off.”
“Really. This whole thing started because you didn’t want them to be big, and now you do?”
“Is that so wrong?” Karyn asked.
“No, of course not kitten.” Jon squished Karyn’s new breasts into place and gave them a little squeeze, poking her claws into them just a little bit, but not painfully. The two of them kissed.
"Your turn, Jon," Karyn said with a smile, her long tail swishing excitedly, dragging Jon's around with it. "Hold forward your paws, lovergirl."
Jon did as asked and Karyn removed them. And then after concentrating, produced four new front paws for Jon.
"Four for me too, huh?"
"Of course. You wouldn't want to be stuck with two human hands, now would you Jon?"
"Oh of course not," Jon said with a laugh.
Jon held forward her hands, and Karyn installed her new paws.
Karyn concentrated some more and produced two more black-furred appendages. "Feet too, and I also want to redo your tail so that it’s as sensitive as mine. You're not getting away without getting the whole package."
"Meow," Jon said coyly as Karyn replaced her feet. Then, as promised, Karyn replaced her tail with one that looked the same, but which could be the source of excitement that the human mind could hardly imagine. Not so sensitive that any incidental touch would send her into a paralyzing climax, but only with rough stroking. Jon felt an electric twinge of pleasure just from it being attached and assimilated into her nervous system. Jon was now as furry and sensitive as Karyn. "So what now?"
"Now we go out and turn more people into cat-people, of course," Karyn answered. "We're not going to stop until everyone is with us, until we take over the world."
"They're Pinky, they're Pinky and the Brain, Brain, Brain, Brain, Brain," Jon sung.
"Hey, we're cats, not mice," Karyn objected.
"Narf!" shouted Jon.
"Stop that," Karyn giggled.
They cleaned themselves up and got dressed. They were pleased to see that their shirts spontaneously adjusted to their extra arms, while their pants and underwear automatically changed to accommodate their new tails, and even their shoes reshaped for their new back paws. That was part of the original condition of the power, after all, though it was possible it would only work while the new parts were being put in. And just in time. They left Karyn's room and approached the front door of her house, only for Karyn's parents to open it, and stand in astonishment of the two furry four-armed young cat-women standing in their house.
"Hi mom, dad," Karyn said. "We have a surprise for you."
"Karyn?" her mom said.
Karyn pulled some new furry body parts out of nowhere, barely holding one in each of her kitty paws.
"Jon, could you help me in, convincing my parents to join our cause?"
Jon sighed and pulled some body parts into existence as well. "Well this isn't awkward at all."
"Jon?" Karyn's dad asked, before drifting into a blank stare, as Karyn used her hypnosis power. They couldn't risk her parents running off before their conversion to cat-people, after all.
