The two burst into Jon's house and frantically stumbled up the stairs together. Karen nearly tripped over her platform heels and Jon was still uncomfortable in her new body causing her to slam her oversized hips into the sofa end table. The pair dove into Jon's room. Jon quickly stripped a box out from under the bed and opened it. Karen respectfully ignored the Hardblush comics and romance novels in the box. That was clearly from Marie, not Jon. Still, a snickering thought passed through her mind when she saw a copy of Fifty Shades of Grey. Apparently Marie was a little nymph. Her thought was interrupted when Jon declared the obvious. "It'sh not here! Maybe.. Maybe Zhoe hash it!"
Jon scrambled to his sisters room and threw the door open. Immediately her jaw dropped.
Through the door she saw her sister cuffed to the headboard of her bed. A pale girl resembling Athena was sitting by her side meeting Jon's gaze. Without even breaking the gaze the pale girl slowly moved a pillow on top of Zoe's erection, hiding it from view... Wait... Zoe's erection!?!
"W-what'sh going on here!" Jon stammered. "Zhoe, where'sh the rock!"
Zoe takes in a sharp breath. "M-Marie! I'm so sorry. I... I!"
Athena interrupts the pair. "Maybe you should leave, Marie. Zoe can talk to you downstairs."
Jon flustered, but nodded and hastily closed the door.
Karen raised her eyebrow. "What was going on in there?"
Jon just shakes his head. "I... Well... gaah! Let'sh jusht wait downshtairs."
They didn't wait long before Athena and Zoe came down the stairs, in that order.
"What's this all about?" Athena demanded cooly.
"You don't get to ask that!" Karen hissed. As the redhead spoke Athena's eyes grew wide. They darted to Zoe, then back to Karen. "Karen?"
Karen's brow knitted in response, and she responded indignantly "What?"
Athena looked to Zoe. "You weren't lying. I... actually thought it was just another trinket. I didn't know it was really magical."
Zoe pleads. "I told you!"
Karen immediately bristles, her hair practically stands on end like a wildcat. "You mean you did this?!"
Jon steps between the three and holds up her hands. "SHTOP!" She takes a deep breath. "First, the shtone. Give it here."
Athena squints her eyes, then bears it from her pocket. Jon goes to take it back from her, but she pulls her hand away. "Knock next time."
"What? Jusht give it here!"
"I said knock next time."
"Fine whatever, now hand it over." She snatches the stone from the pale girls hands and sticks it in her own pocket. "Now what happened? What did you wish for this time?"
Zoe crumples to the couch, and begins to tear up as she tells of Sarah's betrayal. "I... I'm so sorry. She told me what you did to me" Jon raises an eyebrow at that one, but lets her continue. "I thought that maybe I could just fix things. I didn't know she was going to double cross me, and when she wished for all those nice things for our family, I thought she was actually trust worthy." Athena sits next to her and wraps her arm around her shoulders.
"Breath girl... It'll be ok..."
Zoe nods and takes a deep breath followed by a shuddering sigh. "W-When Athena came through... Well... What's done was done... and ... we were just ... well. I was upset and just wanted to have fun and Athena was so confident... She totally kicked Sarah's ass."
Athena interrupts her. "I didn't know the stone was actually magic." She looks at Karen. "I always thought you were sexy, and wished you'd be a goth babe too." She smirks. "Just like my Zoe." Jon shook her head in residual shock at that one. "I made a few other wishes too. That Zoe and I would always be beautiful, and I wished for a chest full of... toys." She smirks and glances to Zoe. "Which I didn't think to check for."
Jon begins to massage her temple. "God, Zoe. Things were finally starting to settle down. We even had the upper hand on Sarah, and you had to mess it all up again... Sarah probably didn't even grant those wishes about you being beautiful or about helping our family."
Zoe interjects. "No! The ones about our family were granted. I saw the stone flash and everything!"
Athena looks indignant and follows up. "Besides, Zoe was trying to help. It wasn't her fault the megabitch betrayed her trust. I was the one who wished this on Karen, not Zoe, so lay off of her."
Karen snaps. "Zoe was the one who didn't trust us after we trusted her with the stone! I thought we were friends Zoe, why would you do this?"
Jon holds up her hand again. "Look, let'sh jusht try to do damage control. Maybe Sharah's in a good mood if she got rid of the negative wishesh we put on her."
Jon holds the stone tightly in her hand and declares. "I wish Zhoe and Athena could remember thingsh from before the wishesh." Seconds ticked by and nothing happened. Zoe breathed a sigh of relief and cried out. "Marie! No! I don't want to be a cheerleader again!"
Jon could only shout in shock. "What?!"
Zoe looked away and mumbled. "S-Sarah said I was a cheerleader before, and that you and Karen changed me without my permission because you were jealous."
Jon wanted to be angry... She really did, but for the life of her she could only laugh. "Zoe, you could never be a cheerleader in any reality." She wasn't sure if that was a compliment or insult, but it seemed to comfort Zoe and she tried again "I wish Zhoe and Athena could remember thingsh from before the wishesh becaushe Sharah wanted everyone to remember everything so it'd be harder!" Jon wasn't sure if Sarah could hear the full wish like that, but a few moments later the flash washed through the room.
The goth lovers shook their heads and viewed each other with wide eyes. Zoe turned to Jon and tears started to bead up in her eyes. "Jon... Oh my god Jon I'm so sorry. You were Marie, and I thought you had changed me. Oh god!"
Jon sighed, and offered up her arms to her sister taking her into an embrace. Karen rolled her eyes but smiled, and Athena offered an embrace from behind. When Athena and Zoe sat back down Athena put some space between them, but after a blushing Zoe scooched right next to her Athena could only smirk and put her arm back around the girl.
"So what now?" Athena asks.
"Well, I don't think we'll be able to pull one over on Sharah again, so I guessh we'll jusht have to hide the stone and hope for the besht. At leasht until I think of something else." She shakes her head. "We definitely can't give it to her. I can't imagine what she'd do with that much power." Jon sighs. "For now, let me jusht write down the wishesh you made, as exactly as posshible. I'm trying to keep a record of them sho we know what to expect."
Jon produced a yellow notepad and began to jot down everything they said bullet list style. As she thought about her actions she considered that this was probably another habit of Marie's rather than his old self, but it was effective, so why not do it? She began the list and between Athena and Zoe they communicate what was wished to the best of their ability.
"I wish that...
**mom didn't have to work so hard/ made more money so she could spend time with us"
** Jon/Marie and Zoe were still friends after everything is fixed."
**Marie would do great at cheer practice at least until everything is fixed."
** for now Sarah could only make wishes to fix these other wishes, and nothing else."
X Zoe and Athena would stay sexy goths for the rest of their lives."
* Karen was a hot bi goth, like Zoe and Athena.
X Zoe had a secret stash of 'toys'"
Jon put a little X by the one's he though Sarah wouldn't actually grant. "Ok, is that everything?"
Athena smirks, "Everything I'm willing to share."
Jon rolls her eyes. "Fine... I guessh thish ishn't too bad."
Karen looks over the list and sighs. "At least I have my old hair and breasts back, even if I have a bald spot..." She rubs the smooth patch of scalp on the right side of her head. "And apparently I'm bi now... And goth..." She grits her teeth and grumbles.
Jon rubs her back and looks at her sympathetically. "We're going shopping Saturday too, remember? We can always get you some clothes like your old ones."
Karen nods and shoots him a sly grin. "Oh how could I forget our trip to the beauty parlor."
Jon flusters. "I-I only agreed to that because I thought Sarah would break before her first game as a transsexual and let us undo everything."
Karen laughs. "Well tough luck. I still need you to do it before I can wax or put on some makeup, so we're going." She titters. "Besides, Montanna couldn't wait to get her nerdy friend in a spa."
Jon sighs with exasperation, then looks at the two goths. "Zoe, I'm not really in the mood, sho you can explain everything to Athena, Karen and I will be in my room if you need anything."
Zoe nods as the two go up the stairs, leaving her and Athena alone. She looks to the Athena. Athena looks to her. Athena smiles. Zoe Blushes. Athena hooks her finger through the ring in Zoe's collar and begins to lead her upstairs.
"That's right Zoe, you're going to have to tell me everything." She raises an eyebrow. "And by the way..." She snaps her fingers and Zoe 'eeps!' as her baggy sweatpants are immediately tented by her member. Athena smiles widely. "Apparently Sarah DID grant that wish~" She coos as she slams the door behind them and pushes zoe onto the bed.
