"You're my mistress?" Gary asked.
"Well, yeah, Gary. Did you lose your memory or something? I know your wife thinks you've kinda lost your mind lately, but my god. Is it because of the stone?"
"The stone?" He was still trying to assess the situation. He completely forgot about the stone, which is ironic since that's the reason he was a Jenny's house in the first place. "Right, the stone." He looked down at it in his hand. "I could wish for something to make all this right," he said, mainly to himself, but Karyn overheard him.
He waited for a moment or so thinking of what to wish to fix this situation. He couldn't possibly have a mistress. Especially one that was still in high school. He loved his wife, and never wanted to cheat on her. There had to be a way to fix all of this. He thought back to the wish he made in the kitchen, thinking it was that wish that made Karyn his mistress. But, it seemed Karyn was impatient and came around to his side of the car and snatched the stone from him.
"Hey!" he yelled in surprise.
"Gary, how hard is it to make a wish? I guess I'll have to make one."
"No, wait."
But it was too late. Karyn held the stone and said "I wish ..."