Joel's breathing had gotten more relaxed. When I looked at him over my shoulder, he was smiling. "That feels... nice, human. Keep going." he said. I rolled my eyes and realized that I was close, but not quite there. I moved a bit further down and I could feel his breath hitch. I took that as a good sign. I massage with a bit more pressure and I was rewarded with his first moan. I smirked as I leaned forward and began to lick at the area. I smelled and tasted like fish, but I ignored it. More moans were let out as my massaging and licking eventually revealed a pink line among the yellow scales. I moved there immediately. Joel began to buck his hips. "Wha-what in the world... are yo-you doing to me, d-damn human! My ge-genital slit is not a toy or a... s-snack!" he panted out as the waves of pleasure washed over him. It was probably his first time with oral sex. After another 3 minutes of stimulation, his fish dick slowly emerged out of the slit. It looked like a dolphin's. That was to say, a gray wriggling tentacle. When it had reached 5 inches, I stopped. I did not need it at full mast. I needed length.
Already naked, I was fingering myself while I was sucking him off. I was bisexual and while I was being faithful to Suzie, everyone knew that sex with NPCs did not count as cheating. If I could save his life and get some merman dick in the process, I was all for it. I felt that I was ready for taking him inside me. Especially since his dick was so thin at the tip. I shifted and grabbed his dick. I gave it a few pumps with my hand. Joel hissed. "Careful! It's not spawning season yet. I can't produce any milt yet!" I let the pressure in my grip relax as I placed it at my hole. It was wriggling around from the stimulation. I had to be precise and firm. I sank down on it and gasped. It was just swirling around in my ass. Joel gasped too. He seemed to glow with a blue aura. "I see what your ploy is. I can take it from here." he said as he grabbed my hips. Joel bucked up into me. Not only was he going harder in me than I was ready for, but he was also getting more erect as he got aroused by the situation. Luckily for me, he was a virgin and a fish with no cum. It lasted 3 minutes tops. He was still deep in my guts though.
11 inches were all in me when he jerked and shuddered. I assumed that he was done. I was barely able to pull myself off his dick. "I think you're going to stay male from now on." I said. Joel looked at me closer. "You have allowed me to keep my pride as a warrior intact. I will forever be grateful to you. " I nodded as I shakily got to my feet. I looked at Jethro. He got the hint and crawled over to me. I could hear the scrape as his scales met the very rough stone of the cave. Jethro's move was so sudden and so unorthodox that none of the others even reached out to stop him. Once he was out of the water, I just flopped on his groin. He grunted in displeasure. "Sorry. As you might have guessed, my human ass was never meant to take something so long inside. You're going to have to wait while I recover some stamina." He just rolled his eyes. Jethro did not care about my feelings. He wanted to keep being male. "Let me take care of you first." I licked and sucked him off. This time, I knew exactly where to aim for. When his fish dick began to emerge, I shifted my hips so I could take it in me right away.
