The choice was obvious. He'd make the sexiest girl he knew into his girlfriend: Sarah McMillan. Never in a million years would Jon have a chance with her, but with his new "ability", she was his for the taking. And she wouldn't know the difference.
Her house wasn't that far away, so Jon just walked there. Shortly after ringing the doorbell, the front door opened, revealing a disgusted Sarah. "What are you doing here, you loser?"
Jon smiled.
"What the hell are you grinning at?"
"You're my bisexual girlfriend," Jon said.
Suddenly, Sarah's face brightened. Jon knew reality had changed, although there was nothing noticeable yet, besides Sarah's change in behavior.
"Jon! Thank god you're here." She grabbed his arm and pulled him inside, then began to kiss him deeply. "I've waited all day to be with you."
Jon was loving this!