The tabby who had replaced Jon's mother shooed the sub-human out the door, but left it open....a pack of cats tramped in...in a variety of colors and genders...and began to circle Jon and Karyn...
They pushed the two humans toward the couch, until they fell onto it. Then, they made no more moves...as if they were keeping the two prisoner...and they felt it.
The tabby called upstairs. "Dinnertime." There was no dinner...at least not in the food sense.
Zoe and Mikey came downstairs and were immediately set upon by a pair of kittens. Before long, there were two new ape-like beings being shooed out as strays.
Karyn and Jon were too frightened to think of anything...such as deciding to undo the wish. They didn't even know if it could be undone until the wish was completed...