"Hey," Karyn said, starting down at her breasts. She looked up into Jon's eyes and immediately looked back down. Jon, meanwhile, kept glancingly around the room, also unable to keep eye contact.
The room was filled with silence except for the steady rain above them, the room glowing in the flickering light of the fire place. A low rumble of thunder sounded in the distance.
"So..." Karyn said. "I take it Nadia and Lisa were given you a show, as usual." Jon looked at her in surprise. "Lisa and Nadia?" he asked. "Yeah, Nadia has greeted you whenever you get home ever since she volunteered for that program that bound her to you. And Lisa's joined her ever since she was over here last week and made a wish that made her just like Nadia."
Jon closed his eyes and signed internally. Since Karyn and Lisa knew about Lisa's wish, they would believe that Lisa accidentally changed herself to be like Nadia, instead of knowing Jon's wish to make Nadia like Lisa actually came second. Only he knew the truth. "Yeah, they did," Jon admitted.
Jon looked at her and saw she was licking her lips. He realized she was trying to lick up the precum around her mouth. Noticing his gaze, she pulled her tongue back in and looked away. Jon reached up with his loose robe and gently wiped her mouth. "Thanks," she whispered.
Jon nodded, but said nothing.
Finally, Jon whispered "I'm so sorry." Karyn immediately shook her head, her long hair trailing behind her as she did. "No, I'm sorry." Jon looked at her. "What do you have to be sorry for? I did... this," he gestured towards her. She sighed. "It was both of our faults. Neither of us respected the power of the stone enough. You were a dick for trying to force yourself on me. I was a dick for hurting you." She paused, then scoffed. "And now I'm just a dick," she said dryly.
"I'll find a way to fix you," Jon said, his voice filled with more confidence than he felt. Karyn smiled at him. It was soft, but unconvinced. "Jon, wishes can't be reversed. But it's ok. I'll be ok," she said softly.
"I shouldn't have made the wish to make you forget," he said. Karyn shrugged her armless shoulders and looked up at him. "Maybe it was for the best. I had a week to get used to not being human. Hell, I still remember all of the fake memories from the reality where I was only your dick. I remember your first erection... your first blowjob... when you lost your virginity..." she trailed off. Jon watcher her, her expression zoning out as she was caught in the vivid memories. Jon watched her throb and saw her tilt her head back, knowing she had just had another pulse of precum run through her body and enter her mouth. He watched as her mouth moved as she swished it around, appearing to savor it.
Karyn suddenly came back to the present and looked up at Jon with an expression of guilt as she quickly swallowed and looked away. "Karyn," he said softly. She said nothing and didn't look at him. "Karyn, what's up?"
"Nothing," she said defensively. "Is that the truth?" Jon pressed. Karyn opened her mouth and looked up to him, but as soon as she met his eyes, she closes her mouth and looked away. Jon sighed. "Karyn, honestly, what are you afraid to say?"
"I like it," Karyn said instantly.
"What?" Jon asked, thinking he was misunderstanding her. "I like being your penis," she said.
"You... like it?" Karyn nodded enthusiastically, causing her entire length to bob between her legs. "I had always been bi-curious before, but was always afraid to tell you. And then, to not just be pleasured by a woman, but to be a penis being pleasured? It felt so good. The pleasure was indescribable. Every waking moment, I hoped that you would whip me out and have a new pussy to stick me in. Or a mouth to suck me. A hand to stroke me. Fuck it all, even an asshole. Fuck, Jon, do you know how much I love it when you stuff me up a tight little asshole?!" she screamed.
"I love it! But how can I tell you that?! How can I tell you that I want to be a body part? Your body part? Your penis?" She sobbed. "I'm so confused. I want to be human too. I miss having a life. I want to have time away from this, to be an actual person, but I don't want to lose this. Even spending all day in your pants is nice. It's comforting and I don't have to worry about anything. And I'm never alone. You were always there. Always taking care of me. I see now that you were treating me like your best friend, but... dammit, Jon... I was so proud to be your dick!"
Jon watched in silence as Karyn cried her eyes out. He thought back to his original wish to make her forget being human and almost threw up. "Karyn, is this because I wished for you to not be upset with the way I used you over the past week? Are these thoughts because they're the only feelings I let you have?"
She shook her head. "No. If anything, that's made it easier. I am not mad at you, and I don't feel like I should be. The regular me would have been angry just because I wouldn't have known how to deal with these feelings. Instead, I'm just confused and scared of what you'll think of me." Jon sat in silence, letting Karyn calm down. After a few minutes, he whispered "Karyn."
"Yeah, Jon? Oh! Sorry, I didn't realize I had been crying," she said, breaking out of Jon's questioning power and feel her wet face. "I have a question," Jon said. "And I want you to promise me that you'll be honest." Karyn nodded, but said nothing, her face full of apprehension.
"Are you upset because you enjoyed it and don't want it to end?" Karyn's eyes went wide as she looked into his. She clenched her jaw a chocked on a sob, her eyes again filling with tears. Jon said nothing, but continued to stare into her eyes. After several moments, Karyn nodded morosely.
"I'm a freak," she sobbed.
"No, you're not," Jon said reassuringly. Karyn shook her head as her tears flowed. "Yes, I am! Because I want to be like this!"
"Then I'm a freak too because I like having you like this as well!"
The outburst surprised both of them. And they stared at each other in silence. "You're my best friend. This past week has been... weird. But exciting. I love having you this close. You're the most intimate person in my life. I want you to be able to be a human again. But... I'd miss this..." Jon admitted.
Karyn snuffled again, and looked away. "Jon," she said quietly, "that may be my fault." Jon furrowed his brow. "What?" he asked in confusion.
"When I thought I was only a penis... I used the stone to make a few wishes..."
Jon slumped back in shock, Karyn bobbing as he moved. He had been changed, and never even knew it! "What? How?" he asked in confusion. "I ate through your underwear and the lining of your pocket and got to the stone. I wished the holes closed when I was done so you wouldn't suspect anything." Jon silently admitted to himself that it was a good plan, and wondered if he ever would have thought of it. "What did you wish?" he asked, bracing himself. "Well..." she started, "you weren't using me, so I wished that you would enjoy using me more and stop being so upset all the time."
The revelation hit Jon like a lightning bolt. He had been enjoying himself. Even during times when he started to get upset, he had always experienced a wave of calmness passing over him, making him forget about his worries. Outside of today, he could not remember a time in his life when he had ever been constantly upset by something.
"Well..." Jon said taking it all in, "it might be for the best. I always feel this sense that everything will be better in the future whenever I get upset. That must be your wish. I must have been constantly upset before you made the wish. It was probably working overtime today, too. I've been trying to not freak out ever since you remembered everything this morning."
"Yeah," Karyn said. "It's just a lot to take in, realizing you're a human being and not just a penis. Especially when you're up a girl's ass while another one's sucking your balls."
"Up a girl's ass? But I didn't-" Jon stopped. In his version of reality, only Lisa had been around and she had only been starting a blowjob when Karyn remembered everything. In this reality, he must have been in the middle of having anal sex with one of them when Karyn's revelation occurred. "I'm sorry," he whispered.
"Don't be. I asked you to fuck Lisa's ass with me." She paused, then sheepishly asked "Do you promise not to judge me?" Jon nodded, and Karyn smiled timidly. "I would kind of like to do it again and be able to finish," she admitted sheepishly.
Even after hearing Karyn's confession under the influence of his questioning power, Jon was still surprised to hear her so readily request that he stick her up a girl's ass. Even as he heard her say it, he felt himself growing harder and felt his cock, Karyn, throb. She hummed pleasantly, reveling in his arousal. "I guess that's a 'yes'," she said.
Jon gave a single, sarcastic laugh. "Kind of hard to keep anything from each other anymore." Karyn smiled up at him. "To be honest, Jon, that's one of the things I like about this... situation." Jon smiled and ran his fingertips along her tiny head, brushing the hair out of her face. However, her head was also still the head of his dick, and the gesture was not just tender, but arousing as well. "Yeah, me too," he admitted.
"Oh," Karyn said, remembering her train of thought. "I also wished that you enjoyed using the stone, enjoyed using Lisa, and that everyone thought your cum tastes as good as I think it does."
Jon laughed. "Wait, you mean I used to have normal tasting cum? Damn, I have memories the first time I got a blowjob and the girl was going on and on about how good it tasted. That was you changing things?" Karyn could only grin sheepishly. "Yeah, sorry. As for the others, you weren't spending time with Lisa like you were Nadia. I think it was because she was changed by a wish and not by actually volunteering for the transformation processes, and you seemed to feel guilty. And as for the stone, well... I enjoyed seeing what the wishes would do and didn't want you to stop." Jon nodded. "Well, for as long as I've had it I remember having a strong desire to use it and enjoying it when I did. And I have used it, haven't I?"
"Yeah. You have the coolest house ever. Your sister has two girls for tits, one of which was a stuck up bitch cheerleader, so that's double awesome. Only thing is, I haven't seen any girls changed by your party wish."
Jon looked at her in confusion, but then realized his mistake. He had made a wish allowing him to notice the transformed girls, but didn't include anyone else in that wish. Even knowing that changes were made, Karyn and Lisa didn't recognize them. And Karyn still didn't realize that Sarah had been turned into Zoe's vagina. Jon smiled, getting a kick that Karyn wouldn't notice any of the girls, not even the ones in his own house. It was like a private joke that he didn't want to let her in on yet.
"They're around. I'll point them out sometime, ok?" Karyn nodded, then fell silent before asking "So... what do we do now?" Jon shrugged. "What can we do now? We deal with this until we think of something."
Karyn nodded, tears in her eyes. "Yeah. Hey, thank you, Jon. Thanks for taking care of me and... understanding." Jon smiled down at her. "Of course. I'll do anything I can to help."
"Anything? No judging?"
He nodded. "In that case, I have a favor I need to ask of you." Jon nodded and waited. "Can you... you know... jack me off? I am so horny that I can't take it anymore." Jon chuckled. "Sure. Want me to call Lisa or Nadia in?"
"No," she said quietly. "Can you do it? Right now, I want it to be just you. Just... us."
Jon nodded again and gently reached down, taking her into his hand. She moaned and twitched even as he tighten his grip around her. "Thank you, Jon... thank you..." she gasped. Her eyes were closed and her face was covered in the precum she had been holding back. Soon, Jon was pumping away furiously, Karyn moaning loudly as he caressed her sensitive body.
"Karyn! I'm close! I'm close!"
"I know! I know! I can feel it! Oooooh fuuuuuuuuck!" she screamed as the two reached orgasm. Jon watched as Karyn twitched and shook, her whole being caught up in the sensations pulsing through her. The thick ropes of cum shooting out of her mouth landed on the thick carpet and hearthstones between them and the fireplace.
Jon watched as Karyn throbbed and twitch with aftershocks. "Thank you, Jon. Thank you," Karyn whispered sleepily. Her body was going limp and their cum was dripping from her slacked open mouth as she passed out. Soon, she was asleep between his legs.
"Lisa," Jon said aloud to the empty room.
Moments later, the door to Jon's room opened and Lisa stepped inside. She was still dressed in the same maid uniform and stood at attention obediently. "Yes, Master?" Jon gestured to his crotch and the floor. "Can you please clean this up.
Lisa let out a squee and rushed forward. She dropped to her knees and enthusiastically licked the remaining drops of cum from Karyn's mouth before she turned to the carpet. Jon was surprised to see her actually trying to lick it up, but it was a useless effort as it was already soaked in. "Master," she said, standing up, "in the future, I am more than happy to do anything you need to avoid making such... messes." She gave him a wink. "In the meantime, I will fetch the carpet cleaner."
"Thanks, Lisa," Jon said as she headed for the door. "By the way," he called after her, "where's Nadia?" Lisa smiled then turned around and bent over. Like Nadia, Lisa was wearing no panties with her uniform. However, Lisa had something Nadia didn't. Tucked in her ass crack, the flat base of a butt plug could be seen sticking out of her asshole. It appeared to be latex, and its tan-ish brown color seemed similar to the skin tone of-
"I left her the ability to wiggle a little," Lisa said proudly. "She feels absolutely divine." With that, Lisa left the room with Nadia the butt plug firmly up her ass.
"Looks like Nadia made it up Lisa's ass before you did," Jon said to the sleeping girl between his legs, giving her body a small stroke. Karyn hummed happily at his touch, but remained asleep.
Jon looked up and stared into the fire. He relaxed as he watched the flames dance. After a few moments of peaceful silence, Jon realized that the rain had finally stopped.
