Jen, Joseph, and Karyn started to make their way to Jen's house. Jen managed to pull Karyn aside privately to talk with her.
"Karyn, we've got a problem," Jen said, "It has to do with the wishing stone."
"Oh no, what did you wish for?"
"On accident, I gave Joseph a free wish for his birthday. He then used that wish for a hundred more wishes that act exactly like the stone. However, I made a wish that he can't remember the wish after he says it. He has ninety-five wishes left."
"Okay," Karyn said, trying to take it all in, "What wishes has he used so far?"
"You heard one of them, to not go to school today, which set off the fire alarm."
"I thought that was a little too convenient."
"He also... also wished me to be a... a girl," Jen managed to get out with a blush.
Karyn gave her a blank stare. "You mean, you haven't always been a girl?"
Jen nodded. "I have all of the memories as a girl, but I'm a guy."
"I can't even imagine you as a guy. What about all those slumber parties we had?"
"Never happened."
"What about the BBAB?"
"Never ha... What's the BBAB?"
"Big Boobs Against Bimbos. It was a club we were going to start to rebel against the cheerleaders. You mean you're big sexy breasts are from a wish?"
"That never existed in either reality. And technically, your big breasts came from a wish too."
"You got me there. So what are we going to do?"
"Just play along with any wish you hear as if it's reality. I'm going to try to make him wish me back to being a guy. I can't use the rock to make any adjustments on me from his wish."
They reached Jen's home. Time to prove that Jon never existed in this reality.