Later that afternoon, Karyn answered the door with a grin that was a cross between a knowing smile and a leer. "Hey, Jon-boy. Come on upstairs. Mom isn't home for another hour."
As soon as they entered Karyn's room, she shut the door and gave him a firm shove. Her bed caught the back of his legs, and Jon fell back onto her mattress. Karyn followed right behind, one hand firmly on his chest, pinning him, while she got on top and straddled his prone body. "It's been a few days since we've been able to be alone like this," she winked, then gestured to her chest. "And you haven't had the chance yet to enjoy the new girls, either. Time we took care of that." In one fluid move, she reached down and pulled her blue sweater dress up and over her shoulders.
Jon's eyes bulged. "Karyn, what are you doing? What about the curse!"
Karyn rolled her eyes with a smile. "What? I'll set a timer for 20 minutes, and get the dress back on with more than enough time to spare before I get a physical penalty. It won't take me ten minutes to get a dress back on, Jon." She hefted her larger breasts from the accidental wish, looking down at him. "Now, what do you think about these? Pretty nice, right?"
Jon stared. "Wait, you're happy with your breasts now?"
Karyn gave him a strange look. "Yeah, of course. Remember how I accidentally got Sarah's breasts last year as a physical penalty for taking off her pink jacket, and how much we both liked them? That's why getting the wishing stone was a perfect solution."
"Karyn, you didn't mean to make that wish the other day. It was an accident."
"What? No, that was the first wish we agreed to make. I just accidentally left their size generic instead specifying them to be exactly Sarah's size."
"Karyn, none of that happened."
Karyn was still straddling him, but now sat back on her heels. "Jon, you don't remember any of this?"
Jon looked at her a little guiltily. "Karyn... not only did none of that happen, before the other day, we had never even kissed."
"Jon, we've had sex, like, DOZENS of times!" Karyn's eyes were bulging.
"No, Karyn, I'm trying to tell you. Before this month started, yeah, I definitely had feelings for you, but we'd never actually done anything. And then you kissed me at school as if we were a thing and now you're on top of me, and seriously, I'm not complaining, you're my best friend and the chance to be with you is amazing, and now clearly I'm rambling, but Karyn, it's like I made that one wish for things to be interesting and it radically changed so much that I'm still struggling to keep up." Jon took a deep breath, then squinted his eyes. "Please don't kill me."
Karyn sat there, blank-faced, then pulled her dress back on. "Sounds like we need to talk this through, and that might take longer than I'm willing to take a physical penalty for." Jon couldn't read what she was thinking, and was beginning to panic about much he might have screwed up their friendship when he screwed up the town, too.
She swiveled her legs so she was sitting next to his prone body on the bed. "Let's just... look... okay, how am I different? Compared to what you remember?"
Jon slowly sat up, thought, and slowly answered. "You're more confident in yourself. I don't know how much of that is because of how October is different in town. I mean, Sarah was always an incredible bitch, and now she's strangely kind and supportive. Maybe the whole 'spending a month in other people's shoes' did that to her. But for you - you're more social than we ever were. You have an air of authority in the way you move and interact with people. I have no idea how you dress normally when it isn't October, now, but I'm guessing that it's more than hoodies and baggy sweaters. You would never have wanted to change your body, but I guess now with your greater self-confidence, you're open to making yourself into whatever self is most satisfying to you. And you seem several steps further along where our friendship might have gone in the world I know." He reached out and took her hand. "I entirely see how this Karyn could come into being, and she seems just as incredible as the Karyn I knew. I just need to catch up, and I hope you'll allow me the space to do so."
Karyn sat there with that, then a smile slowly tugged at the corner of her mouth. "And that kind of response is EXACTLY the same as the Jon I know and love." She tossed her hair and leaned in, resting her forehead against his. "So what you're saying is that you remain the same Jon, while I'm next-level Karyn. And even though we've made out hundreds of times and have known each other intimately in a whole bunch of ways, you're starting from scratch. From my perspective, you've been reset and get to experience us, as you and I currently are, all over again."
"Y-Yes?" Jon stammered.
"So you don't know how I can blow your mind, but you're going to bring back some 'new love' enthusiasm to what's already been happening for months?" Karyn looped a hand around each of Jon's braids.
"Yes?" Jon murmured.
"And you'll follow my lead, like you always have, but now you'll REALLY follow my lead?" Karyn nipped at his lip, and slowly pulled back with her teeth before letting go.
"Yes," Jon whispered.
Karyn smiled. "Alexa, set a timer for 20 minutes." She pushed Jon back onto the bed and pulled her dress off once again.
"Now, Jon, do you like my new breasts?" she asked coyly.
"... do you like them?" Jon asked after a moment.
"Very much so," she smirked.
"... then yes, I love them." Jon breathed.
In one fluid motion, Karyn reached up under Jon's sweater dress, grabbed onto his leggings, and pulled them down to his knees.
"Welcome to this reality, Jon. Old to me, new to you." Karyn beamed. "Hope you survive the experience."
And she dove down onto Jon with a deep, hard kiss, and began to blow Jon's mind all over again for the first time.
