Staring at Ben’s massive ass, Kurt could imagine all the different ways that this scene was about to play out. He could enter the same hole that Elma had just finished using up or he could force Ben to turn back around and finish what he started. These ideas weren’t bad but one idea seemed to jump out to Kurt more than the other ones. As he stared at Ben’s ass, Kurt began to think about fucking Ben’s tight asshole.
There was no one in the shower that would know if Amanda had ever done anal but it didn’t matter to Kurt. The idea of having Ben get fucked in every hole was too appealing. Additionally, using some mental gymnastics, using the back door was a bit better than fucking Ben’s pussy in regard to how wrong and taboo this all was. It didn’t mean that any of this was a good thing to do but hit lessened the blow even if the rules of the Body Exchange left everything open.
Ben stood there and had no clue what Kurt had in mind as he stood face to face with Elma. While they stood there, Elma finished up washing her body off as she felt like there was no need for her to be there. Deciding it was time to leave Ben and Kurt alone, Elma opened the shower curtain and exited through the other side. Now, the pair had more room in the shower as Ben moved closer to the shower head.
“That was a crazy experience,” Ben said as he could still feel how was his legs were and how stretched his holes were. He believed that everything was done and began to wash off but didn’t know that Kurt wasn’t satisfied. As Ben went back to washing his body off, he bent over which left himself vulnerable and exposed to Kurt who was waiting patiently. Now with a clear view and opportunity to do something, Kurt shuffled forward slightly and aimed his cock towards Ben’s ass. From Ben’s perspective, he felt something tap his ass but didn’t think anything of it until he felt his asshole being stretched to the absolute limit.
“Oh fuck!” Ben screamed as he was hit with a wave of pain along with slight pleasure and surprise. “Gentle! Gentle!” Ben could feel Kurt’s cock more than he could feel Elma’s earlier as Kurt listened to Ben slightly. Slowly, Kurt shoved his cock inside of Ben as even the speed he was going at was a bit too fast. Based on how it felt, Ben immediately could tell that Amanda was usually never fucked in her ass.
Kurt took his time building up speed. His cock continued to stretch Ben who could feel every single inch. Originally, Ben began to bend over like he had done when Elma was fucking him but Kurt didn’t let him do that. Instead, Kurt wrapped an arm around Ben’s body and forced him to stand up straight. Once Ben was in position, one of Kurt’s hands played with Ben’s breasts while the other hand played with his pussy.
All of this was incredibly hot as slowly the pain began to fade and get taken over by immense pleasure. Elma was still in the bathroom and could swear that the moans escaping Ben’s body were louder than ever. She smiled as she got dried off and dressed, enjoying the fact that both herself and Kurt were giving Ben an amazing first night experience. Before Elma exited the bathroom, she heard something that made her laugh to herself.
“I~I~I g~going to c~cum,” she heard Ben squeak out as Ben was about to experience his first female orgasm. Immediately, Ben’s entire body went weak as his legs buckled slightly and his entire body shook. The orgasm was intense as Ben felt like his entire body was about to explode. Did this stop Kurt? No. Kurt didn’t stop fucking Ben’s ass as he wanted to reach his own orgasm. This would take a little bit of time as strangely Ben’s old body could last a good amount of time. Was it because of who he was fucking? It was very possible but it could also be a simple fact that Ben’s old body could last a long time.
The scene continued to play out even after Elma exited the bathroom. Kurt played with Ben’s body while he continued to fuck Ben’s tight hole. Ben could swear that Kurt knew all the right places to touch as a few minutes after his first orgasm Ben reached another. This was then followed by another. And then another. And another. At a certain point, Ben lost track of how many times he came but it didn’t matter. It felt amazing every time but couldn’t compare to when Kurt finally came. Due to his ass being much more sensitive, Ben could feel the small twitches from Kurt’s cock as it motivated Ben to go faster. Ben shoved his body back harder than he ever could, dying to feel Kurt cum. This ended up working as Kurt groaned before pumping his cum into Ben’s ass. It felt amazing to be filled up again as Kurt followed the same method as Elma, keeping his cock inside until every last drop exited. Eventually, he pulled out as Ben fell forward out of breath, leaning against the bathroom wall. Both were spent as the arc had totally wiped them out.
