[Ignoring the fact that Jon and Karyn had left the stone in a locker on the boat, and continuing despite the continuity error .]
"I wish Jon was a female otter for the rest of the night. And that SHE was surrounded by "friendly" males with plenty of fish around to eat." Karyn said with an evil gleam in her eyes before I could snatch the stone back from her.
"KARYN!" I gasped in shock at her wish. Before her name even left my mouth, I could feel the wish taking effect. I shuddered at the sensation of my plumbing re-arranging itself. My outer appearance didn't seem to change too much with the wish, though I imagine it is a bit hard to tell a male otter from a female one just by looking at it. I certainly FELT a bit different though
I was just considering that though when a small pile of fish appeared in front of me. And although I couldn't see behind me, I knew something else had appeared as well. Or rather, SOMEONE else.. SEVERAL someone elses. I could smell their scent, even as tey sniffed the air themselves, catching a whiff of the fresh fish. And fresh female
Which was JUST about he time that the fact that the two moons were in the sky dawned on my instincts .