Before the four had time to pull themselves together, there was a sharp knock on the door and the small window opened up. The pregnant-looking woman peered in at them.
"Ah," she said with a smile, "I see you have made your choices."
"No!" Jon blurted, "this isn't what I wanted!" Karyn and Zoe shook their heads in agreement.
"Very well," said the woman, "what, pray tell, DO you want?" She looked at Jon.
"Um," said Jon, "I want my penis back..."
The woman's smile widened, and she looked to Zoe. "And you?"
Zoe stammered, and said "I want to get rid of... this...", gesturing at the still-rigid cock and balls hanging from her crotch.
The woman looked at Karyn, and said "And you? What would you seek?"
Karyn, who hadn't forgotten about the stone like Jon, considered her long blonde hair and large breasts, and said "I want to have the hair, breasts, and genitals I was born with."
The woman looked at Athena last, and said "And what about you?"
Athena said, "I wish you would let us free so we could return home." Zoe, Karyn and Jon all nodded, feeling foolish that they had not thought to ask for this, but glad that Athena had included them in her request.
The witch nodded, and said "Be careful what you wish for, it may be granted. Once you have coupled with each other, you will fall asleep. When you awake, your wishes will have been granted. Do not seek us again."
With that, the window slid shut, and the four were left looking at each other, bewildered.
Athena walked over to Zoe and took her by the hand, saying "I think there's only one thing we can do now. Are you willing to have sex with me so we can get out of here?" Zoe nodded, and Athena took her to a corner of the room, giving Jon and Karyn a pointed look.
Karyn and Jon made eye contact, and blushed furiously. They held hands and went to the far corner from Zoe and Athena, trying to ignore the moans and soft noises as their naked bodies entwined.
Karyn lifted Jon's hand and placed it on her breast, saying "I guess you should enjoy these before I get my real ones back." Jon felt her soft, firm breast and felt a warm dampness growing in his crotch. Karyn started to kiss his neck, and soon he found himself kneeling with Karyn's large cock rolling around in his mouth. One minute blurred into another, and Jon and Karyn soon forgot about the cold stone floor and the sounds of Zoe and Athena in the far corner. Jon gasped in pain and pleasure as Karyn's huge member thrust into his sopping pussy. Within a few minutes, they were all asleep, entwined in each other's arms.
