"I choose my dad."
Suddenly there was a knock at the door. Karyn and Jon jumped. The door opened and Jon's dad, Alan, came in. Could the wish have acted that fast? If that wasn't unexpected enough, Alan was completely nude.
Jon and Karyn couldn't help staring. Alan seemed completely comfortable standing in front of them both in the nude. "Hey kids," Alan said. "I didn't know you were here, Karyn. I was coming to get Jon for some sex. Do you mind?"
"N, not really," said Karyn. She couldn't believe it! Even with what she had already seen, she couldn't wrap her mind around the fact that her best friend's dad was naked in front of the two of them and seemed so comfortable with it.
"Thanks, Karyn," said Alan. "By the way, you sound different. Is something wrong?"
"N, no," Karyn stammered. "We were playing a game, and I gave myself shark's teeth."
"Oh, you're playing Would You Rather," said Alan. "I love that game! Do you mind if I join in when Jon and I are done?" Alan began to unzip Jon's pants.
"Sure thing, Dad," said Jon, blushing.
"Great," said Alan, pulling down Jon's pant's. "Hey, cute panties, Jon. And, please, call me Alan. We've been lovers ever since you turned thirteen. You've earned the right to call me by my first name."
"Do you want me to leave?" asked Karyn. She felt her control over the the situation slipping.
"Not at all, dear," said Alan. "There's nothing going on that you haven't seen us do before."
By that time, Jon was nude. He was mortified, not only by his nudity, but by his growing lust for his father. He wanted to sleep with his father. With Karyn still watching, he kissed Alan on the mouth and allowed his father to pull him onto his bed.