"Okay, well now it's my turn," said Karyn with some hesitation. She picked up the hat and drew two slips of paper. She drew "swap" and "genitals."
"Oh great," moaned Jon. "Now I'm going to have three vaginas."
Immediately after he said that, he could feel his testicles and penis shrink into his body. Soon enough he had a third vagina, right where one should be on a girl. Jon looked up to see a very uncomfortable looking Karyn.
"You okay?" Jon asked.
"Yeah, but, um, would you mind if I took off my pants. My pants are tight as it is and your penis is um... erect."
Jon said it was fine, after all it was his penis. But he could see that the two penises on her boobs were pretty hard too. Come to think of it, his own vagina was starting to feel wet, and liquid was seeping through his chest. Jon was really horny. And it looked like Karyn was the same, her hand was resting on her dick. He took off his own pants to take a closer look. Why was he so horny?
"Karyn, can I see the two names you picked?" Jon turned over both pieces of paper, but didn't see anything weird about them. He was about to put them down when a third piece of paper dropped to the floor in front of him. He picked it up and read out loud, "horny." It had somehow affected both of them.
"Hmm?" Karyn was staring at him, but was staring to rub her newest dick as well as one of the ones on her boobs. Jon himself was absently rubbing his chest. He couldn't take his eyes of Karyn or her three penises. They locked eyes for what seemed like an eternity before they slowly started moving closer to each other...