Jon stared at Karyn, now for the first time knowing her biggest secret. He had no idea that she was a lesbian.
"What is it, Jon?" Karyn asked. "What did it do?"
He just kept on staring at her. How could she keep something like this from him? He was her best friend!
"Why are you staring at me? What did that wish do?" she asked, getting uncomfortable.
"I ... I know everyone's biggest secret."
"Then why are you staring at ..." Her eyes went wide.
"I had no idea that ..."
"Please. Don't tell anyone. I don't want anyone to ..."
"How could you not tell me?" Jon asked, getting a little upset.
"I was afraid of how you might react. I mean, I would have told you eventually."
"How can I trust you if you keep secrets like that?"
"Jon, I ..."
Forgetting that he was holding the stone, Jon said "I wish ..."