Without taking her eyes off of Maggie, Selena/Tom said, "Cain, I don't really remember if we ever got the rules laid out perfectly, so real quick, let's get this hashed out. You have to do exactly what I say, right?" Selena/Tom licked his lips in anticipation.
Cain, also without taking his eyes off Maggie, said "Not exactly, no. I'm not a genie, but I have the power and free will to change reality how I see fit within certain limits - the main one being that my magic only activates so long as my motivation is in service to you, either helping you out or fulfilling your desires. I was able to change you into a girl yesterday because I felt you needed a lesson in female humility, and given that you asked me to make you better at talking to girls, that was considered okay."
Maggie was getting worried. She was also getting horny, surrounded by three hot guys, all of whom were staring at her with lust in their eyes. Her horniness actually made her more worried, and the fear and anticipation made her hornier. Through the fog of hormones, however, she managed to yell out, "You can change reality? Well then, change me back into Matt! Make me a boy again!"
Cain just shook his head. "Sorry babe, but it doesn't work that way - I turned you into a girl to help Tom get better at talking to girls. Now, he's asked me to leave you that way - you're stuck as a member of the fairer sex until he changes his mind. I currently take orders from Tom - if that changes, I'll let you know. On the bright side though, you turned out fantastic looking - I apparently really do good work." Josh grunted a noise of approval.
Tom/Selena barked a harsh, mirthless laugh. "You're not wrong, Cain. You do superb work. So, if I vocalize a few more desires about Maggie here, they'll come true? And what about anything else?"
"Yep. I don't know how long I'm stuck in service to you, but until I'm not, anything you desire, I'll do. But be specific, otherwise, I get to fulfill them as I see fit." Cain was getting a bit worried about this line of questioning - he had never known Tom to be thorough or to think ahead.
Tom/Selena smiled. "Okay. First, I'd like Maggie to stop whining about being a boy again - it's getting annoying. So, change history and her memories so that only she remembers herself being Maggie - my intelligent, submissive, sexually-adventurous girlfriend." Maggie looked horrified, and started yelling incoherently, before Tom/Selena cut her off with a wave of her hand. "Don't worry Maggie - it's not like you're upset once Cain finishes anyway."
Cain just shrugged, and worked his magic on Maggie. Maggie felt her mind fill with cobwebs, as she struggled to hold onto what little was left of Matt. But it was a futile battle, and soon, Maggie opened her eyes, smiling and walking seductively towards Tom, her boyfriend. Without a word, she placed her plump lips over his and embraced him as though it was for the first time. Tom returned the kiss eagerly, slipping a hand onto her chest and gently fondling her breast over her bra.
Josh looked indignant. He looked at Cain, then at Tom and Maggie - the girl he had worked on, the girl he had claimed. "Tom, that's a little fucked up. I am the one who put in his time. Maggie should be my girlfriend."
Maggie giggled girlishly hearing this, having always put up with Josh for Tom's sake. "What's he talking about, studly?" She asked, using the pet name she had given Tom years ago. "When spoken to, dear." Tom/Selena replied dismissively. This casual display of dominance caused a wave of erotic energy to course through Maggie, and she returned - wordlessly - to servicing his face with her mouth.
Tom/Selena broke off the kiss a moment later, and met Josh's angry gaze. "I hadn't forgotten about you, and I'm prepared to take care of it." Tom/Selena looked over at the nightstand and grabbed the coin he had put there the night before. "We're going to flip."
Josh snorted contentiously, but stood his ground. "What, for Maggie? You already made her your girlfriend, asshole." Tom/Selena smiled, but it was cold and calculated.
"No, not for Maggie, but for your peace-of-mind. Cain, I'm going to flip this coin, and you cannot use your magic to influence the outcome. Is that understood?" Cain nodded his head. "Good. If it lands heads, Josh here becomes, physically and mentally, Maggie's twin sister. If it lands tails, you become, physically and mentally, Josh's dream girl - although, you'll magically remain in service to me. Won't this be fun?" Tom/Selena laughed. Maggie was giggling in the background as Josh and Cain's faces turned ashen grey.
"Why don't you just make her my dream girl?! Why are you doing this?!" Josh asked.
"Because - isn't this just so much more interesting?" Tom/Selena said, tossing the coin into the air.
