(This episode originally written by Amarantha. I deleted a few things and edited it as I wanted to pursue the same storyline with the note destroyed).
The first victim of Mikey's wish stickies lived next door. Jenny, an eight-year-old girl in Mikey's class at school, walked out of her house to find her friends, and noticed a sticky note on the front door when she closed it. Picking it off of the door, she began to read it out loud to herself. "I wish that I would switch genitals with my opposite-sex parent, and that the new genitals worked perfectly and aged normally as if they were still attached to the original, but both of us grew as if we had our original genitals."
Jenny stared blankly at the sticky note and then suddenly had a compulsion to eat it. After she had eaten it, Jenny opened the door. As she walked inside she noticed her panties were incredibly tight under her dress, and had to rush into her room to pull them off. She jumped onto her bed and pulled her panties off. The tip of something she shouldn't have peeked out from under her dress, and as she lifted it up, she shrieked. She had a penis! And a hairy ball sack! Her dress felt somehow dirty now, with these huge new... things resting in it. They looked absolutely huge, and had dark hair around them; her hair was a very light brown.
Her small hand could wrap around the shaft, but only barely. As she stared at it, and the shock wore off, she realized it must be her dad's! And her dad must have her vagina! She giggled at the thought of it despite herself, and suddenly, she heard a voice at her door!