(Using part of the other chapters, I think that given what we know about the stone it wouldn't work that way.)
Meanwhile, back at Jon’s real house, Jill, who identified as Jon but unaware that she wasn’t really him, was relaxing in his bedroom. She was upset at the fact that Karyn was about to give back her potty training, but ended up not doing it for some reason she couldn’t remember. She didn’t know that it was because they swapped lives with Joe and Jill instead.
Jill/Jon then remembered about the stone, there should be no reason that she couldn’t just wish away her diapers. She picked up the stone with Jon’s hands and wished “I wish I was potty trained!” Thankfully, it worked. She walked over to the bathroom and sat on the toilet to do her business like a big boy!
Suddenly as she was on the toilet, Jill had a moment of clarity. Out of nowhere, she didn’t feel right. She felt like she was in the wrong body. Jon’s penis suddenly felt… alien to her, as if it didn’t belong. She suddenly started fantasizing about having sex with men and having a vagina and breasts and feeling like a pretty girl. Jill didn’t know why she felt like this, but unknown to her, it was because of Karyn’s prank on Jon where she switched their personalities back. All that Jill knew is that this wasn’t the body she wanted.
Jill got up off the toilet and picked up the stone again. Hastily, she made a simple wish. “I wish I was a girl… a beautiful one too.” Just like that, her body changed. She looked at herself in the bathroom mirror and admired her beautiful face. She had a curvy hourglass figure, D-cup breasts, painted nails, and long cascading hair. She finally felt like she was in the body that she was meant to be in.
As suddenly as the first time, Jill felt a second wave of clarity as Karyn switched their personalities back. Then it passed. She shrugged.
Jill had wished to be a girl, and that had transformed Jon's body, which Jill was currently in. Jon hadn't heard the wish. So he thought that his body was a girl's body all along. He had become Joana and his personality was Joana's and he and Karyn thought it had been like that all along too. All of reality within the range of the wish, everything anyone remembered about the past, had been changed so that Jon had been a girl, Joana. The only thing that hadn't changed was Jill's memory. Jill in Jon's body remembered being Jon, and she still did, since she heard the wish, but when the personalities were swapped back, she now had Joana's personality and was perfectly happy with being a girl. Her memories of Jon were a loose end caused by the way the wishes affect memory and would go away when Jon swapped back.
Jill knew she was meant to be a guy, Jon, but she had the body that she just wished for. Jill sat down on her bed, which was in a very differently decorated bedroom than before. It had worked out well.
And in the new reality, Jon/Karyn's escapades had played out a little differently.
Deciding to have a little fun at Joana's expense Karyn fished the device out of her pocket and pulled up Joanna's current profile. She decided to leave her in Jill's body but give her all of her own personality and mind back just to see what would happen. She also saw an option next to her name and other details to make her compelled to use the name Jill. She selected this option to see what would happen.
As Joana walked out of the bathroom, Karyn tried to keep a straight face and asked him, "Is everything OK, Jill?"
Joana walked back out of the bathroom and clumsily walked over to the bed, sitting on the edge but keeping her distance from Karyn. Karyn made no effort to cover herself up, lying on her back, with her penis laying proudly on her lap. "You're Jill's husband." Joana looked at her with a frown and said, "And I'm not Jill. I'm Jill... No. Wait. You're my friend Karyn and I'm Jill. God dammit Karyn, this is giving me a headache."
It was finally too much for Karyn and she burst into a loud laugh. Satisfied that she'd had her fun she picked up the device and changed Joana's settings back to where they were a few minutes ago. She left the name changes in place and also turned her speech patterns and attraction to her up a bit higher than they were originally "I just wanted to see how uncomfortable you would be with another woman's husband if you didn't have the personality of Jill. So I swapped your personalities back for a little bit."
"It felt strange because I didn't want to be sleeping with an older man who's married to someone else, but I know in my head that you're really still Karyn. It was all mixed up. But I think I could have eventually gotten used to it even without Jill's personality because I know you're not really her husband. You know it's funny, I wonder what Jill thought when she had her personality back for a few moments. Was she suddenly worried that she was regressed back to high school and there was no way to prove who she was to her her family? Did she call the police?
"Partly. She was unaware of the swap, so she'd have a copy of your memories. She might think high school and your family felt wrong, but she wouldn't remember anything else, so she certainly wouldn't call the police. And by now she's back to just you, just Joana.
