Jon sat down on the bed and took a deep breath, then began. "I know this will sound strange, but ... I know you're into the occult, so ... I mean, the real Athena is ..."
"Real Athena? What are you talking about?" the fake Athena asked.
"You're not Athena. You only think you are. And that woman out there isn't your mother. A bunch of people around town have been ... swapped ... with other people. Listen, I know this all sounds strange, but it's the truth. You're into the occult, right? You must have heard something like this before."
"No, actually. You know, maybe you're just exhausted. The mind can play tricks. You could just be ..."
"I'm not delusional!" Jon yelled, jumping up. "This is happening. Right now!" He got up into the fake Athena's face. "The person you think is Zoe, my sister, is actually a girl named Karyn. And I have to get her back to normal ... before ... before she stays that way forever. I have to get her back to her house! Now!"
The fake Athena was silent, as she stared at Jon with shock.
Jon sat down on her bed and calmed down a bit. "You have to believe me."