(Copying part of Smitty2's episode)
Biff was living a contradictory existence now, he still mercilessly mocked other kids who were "different", even though he was technically a woman who wished he was a man. Other kids were still afraid of him because he was still as physically strong as before. Jon assumed his social stature would be much lower, but besides the other guys on the football team cracking the occasional joke about him, people seemed to treat him the same as they used to. Karyn seemed more sympathetic towards him, but to Jon, Biff was basically still Biff. He decided to make another wish to further things. He could always think up some wishes to change him back. He looked down the hallway where Biff stood with his football buddies, mocking kids as they walked by.
"I wish that today Biff has decided to embrace his new gender." He intentionally was somewhat vague with the wish, just to see what would happen. There was a flash, and Jon saw that Biff was now wearing a plaid skirt and a low cut top. his legs were shaved, and he now had on make-up, although it was obviously his first time attempting to apply it. He also now stood alone, his football buddies no longer seemed to want to associate with him. Steve came up to him and seemed confused, "Hey man, I thought you didn't like all that girly stuff?"
"I... I just wanted to try it, I'm tired of you guys making fun of me. I need to be straight with the world, I'm a woman." he was even trying to speak in a higher voice. "Are we still dating?"
"I don't know, part of the reason I liked you was because it was like hanging out with a guy, but we could also do all the sex stuff and it wasn't gay."
"I understand..." said Biff, sadly.
Jon was watching the scene intently, when Karyn suddenly grabbed the rock from his hand. "Jon! This is cruel! You need to be taught a lesson!"
"Karyn, don't---"
"I... No, I can't do it."
"Okay, give me back the stone."
"No, Jon. Just because I'm not going to make a wish that I didn't even take half a second to think about, I'm not going to leave this alone."
"Karyn, I'm cruel to Biff because he was cruel to me! You just don't remember it because you didn't hear the wish. If a wish is made and someone doesn't hear it, she remembers things as if it has always been that way. I'm not just doing things to him for no reason!"
Karyn thought about that for just a few seconds. Jon hoped she'd return the stone, but she didn't. "Okay, let's say Biff was cruel to you. You made a wish and now everyone remembers the new Biff. The new Biff wasn't cruel to you, at least you never told me he was."
"I wished that he'd be basically the same."
"Yes, but he's still different enough that he hasn't bullied you, or at least you never told me about it. Once you've turned him, or her, into new Biff who doesn't do bad things to you, you have no right to do any further things to her. And you did. Now, how are you going to fix this?"
"First of all, I can't reverse wishes. Second, if I somehow did, he'd be cruel to me again, unless you want me to wish for some mind control."
"Okay, then you can do something. Something that makes things nicer for her, without making her into old Biff."
"I'm not sure I can even change Biff into Biff from five minutes ago."
"Then make your best effort. Do something."
"Sure, can you give me the stone back?"
"If you sincerely make your best effort. I'll wish that you make your best effort to do right by Biff and I'll give you the stone back."
"Fine. Go ahead. Make your wish. I'll do it."
"I wish that after I give Jon this stone back, he'll sincerely make a wish to make things better for Biff." She tossed Jon the stone back.
Jon caught it and said....
