"...I wish your disguises would become 100% real, that you'd both turn into girls who look exactly as you do now."
Jon and Alan looked at each other. Had that wish worked? They couldn't tell, but feared the worst.
Alan felt a tingling in his scalp and grabbed the large, curly wig on his head, only to find his fingers combing through natural, large, curly hair instead. Jon was similarly affected, the long straight blond wig attached replacing his natural hair.
A sudden jolt passed through their bodies and the boys felt the cheap tissue padding on their hips and in their bras instantly became flesh and fat. Jon stumbled forward under the sudden weight and quietly cursed himself for choosing such a large bra in the first place.
That single jolt had done the stone's work throughout the boys' bodies. Their members were gone, replaced by female genitals both externally and internally.
Jon and Alan checked at themselves and each other miserably. They were women. Tall and masculine, with broad shoulders and shades of facial stubble, but still indisputably women.
Sarah and Karyn laughed wickedly. That hurt Jon more than anything, that Karyn was such a willing part of this. Even though he knew that thanks to the magic of the wishing rock, Karyn was no more herself than Jon himself - herself was right now.
"You look like a couple of freaks!" Sarah cackled. "And the best part is, to everyone but the four of us, you've always been those freakish girls!"
"This isn't funny Sarah," Jon pouted. "You can't reverse wishes! Alan and I could be stuck like this for the rest of our lives!"
"Hmm, you're right," Karyn paused thoughtfully. "Well if that's the case then we need to fix you up right away. Can't have a couple of beefy girls called Jon and Alan walking around town can we? You need new names! Alan you could be Alison, and Jon you can be Joy! In fact, I wish those were really your names!"
"Oh no!" Joy gasped.
"What do we do, Joy?" Alison fearfully whispered in her ear. "What'll they do next??"
"We have to get the stone!" Joy said with determination. Suddenly she leapt towards Karyn...