Catgirl Initiation

Jon still couldn't believe his...rather, her predicament. His mind kept racing in circles trying to find ways to counteract the wish, but over and over he failed to come up with a way to change himself back to normal without contradicting the wish.
Karyn noticed his confusion and couldn't help but feel a little bit guilty. She had wished this into happening even though she hadn't really meant it like this, so it was her responsibility to make things right.
A mischievous grin slowly formed on her feline face and she whispered her plan to Sarah. When she heard the plan, Sarah got a grin just as wide as Karyn's. She nodded eagerly at Karyn and couldn't help herself from purring a bit.
"Oh, Jon," Karyn said as she gently stroked Jon's ears, eliciting a reflexive purr. "Hm, that's the name from your old life. Let's give you a new one. Let's see...Juniper! Yes, that fits great! How are you feeling, Juniper?"
Juniper sniffled slightly. "I can't do this! I'm not supposed to be a catgirl! It's just a wish gone wrong!"
"Now now, Juniper, it's not so bad." Karyn continued to stroke her ears. "You like us, right? You'll like being one of us too, I promise."
"But I can't,", Juniper sniffled. "I'll never get used to this!"
Karyn and Sarah winked at each other. "Oh, really?" both asked in unison.
"Yes! It's just..." Juniper gasped, her reply suddenly cut off by a wave of sensation. "Ohhh!"
Juniper found herself completely breathless. Karyn and Sarah had each began to lick one of her nipples, and their scratchy tongues on the sensitive flesh was like nothing she had felt before.
"You see," Karyn said as Sarah continued her licking, "Catgirls are much, much more sensitive than humans. Why do you think we're always so eager to play with humans and each other? You'll find that becoming a catgirl is actually better than anything you could have thought to wish for."
Karyn returned to her licking as Juniper attempted to understand this. It was a simple message, but her mind was so overwhelmed with pleasure that it took a while to comprehend anything else. This felt better than anything she had even imagined before, and she didn't have the focus available to think of much other than how much she was enjoying it.
From Juniper's purrs, the other two catgirls could tell she was very close to her first orgasm as a catgirl. Karyn took this as a cue and slowly moved the tip of her tail towards Juniper's nether regions. She gently nipped at Juniper's nipple at the same time as she thrust her tail deeply into Juniper.
The whole house seemed to shake from Juniper's roar of pleasure, and Karyn instantly knew her timing had been perfect. She brought her tail in and out of Juniper repeatedly, making sure to draw Juniper's orgasm out to be as long and intense as possible.
Juniper's mind was completely flooded by her orgasm. Nothing in her wildest dreams had even approached the sensations when they had merely been playing with her nipples, and this was so much more that she couldn't even think. It seemed to go on for days, every second better than one before.
Karyn and Sarah shared a victorious grin with one another, knowing there was no chance Juniper would be regretting this wish any more. As Juniper finally seemed to be coming down from her orgasm, Karyn gently slid her tail out from Juniper and the two gradually let go of Juniper's nipples. The two laid on either side of her, waiting to see if she would have anything to say.
Juniper panted, exhausted and absorbed in the glow. After several minutes her breathing had slowed enough to squeeze out a few words. "Is...is that what it...it's always like?"
"Not really," Karyn said with a grin. "Since it was your first time, we didn't want to overdo it so we went easy on you." Noting Juniper's speechlessness, Karyn continued. "And, of course, we haven't told you the best part of being a catgirl yet..."
Juniper was completely overwhelmed, but managed to squeak out, "What is?"
"You see," Karyn giggled, "Catgirls have no trouble doing that dozens of times in the same night."
After several moments of silence, Sarah began to giggle. "I think she doesn't believe it," she said with a wink to Karyn. "Maybe we ought to prove it, just so she doesn't begin to suspect us of misleading her."
Karyn winked back. "Yes, that sounds like a good idea."
None of the neighbors got much sleep that night due to the loud noises that went well into the morning.