"Well, let's see...for my first wish, I wish Karyn was more like me." Sarah said.
If Karyn hadn't been frozen by Sarah's wish, she would have at that. Terrified, but unable to cry out, she could only feel her mind cloud over and slow as she became what she hated, a ditzy, shallow cheerleader.
But wait. Maybe things weren't as terrible as they seemed. She was less intelligent, she knew, and she was having trouble focusing her thoughts, but there was something...
Of course! She'd heard the wish! She still remembered who she was!
Slowly putting two and two together, she realized that Sarah didn't really understand how the stone worked. And (miraculously, given her intelligence) she reasoned out that if she could fool Sarah into thinking she had totally become one of her airhead cheerleader lackeys, she might be able to get the stone back.
"Like, Sarah, what are we doing with this loser?" Karyn asked with feigned disgust. She later realized in dismay that she hadn't meant to sound quite so much like a bimbo. She could only hope Jon would realize she didn't mean it.
"Patience Karyn." Sarah responded to who she thought was her newest lackey. Sometimes she surprised herself with her creativity. Not only did she take their wishing rock, but she'd come up with the perfect way to make sure they never got it back. Turning them into the newest addition to her cheerleader entourage. What was that old saying? Keep your enemies closer than your friends? Something like that.
Sarah turned to Jon. Even though he was paralized, she could see the fear in his eyes. She had to wonder if he saw this coming.
"I wish that Jon was more like me and Karyn, including body wise." She said smugly.
Karyn had to struggle to keep her eyes from widening in shock. How could Sarah do this to Jon, too? It was bad enough that she had become a total ditz, but now Jon would have to go through that and becoming a different gender at the same time!
While Karyn was thinking this, Jon's lengthened drastically, changing to the light blonde color shared by Sarah and karyn as it gradually reached his rapidly slimming shoulders. His skin tone darkened as he gained a cheerleader's tanned complexion, while his lips became more full. His eyes turned blue as his chest swelled out into the same busty proportion as the girls he would soon be joining.
When his hips and butt had filled out and his legs had become feminine and hairless, the shock went out of his eyes, replaced by an empty, vapid look. But Karyn thought she glimpsed understanding there, for just an instant. The new Jon seemed to have a mix of Sarah and Karyn's features, with very few of his own remaining.
"Karyn, like, what are you wearing? And, like, why am I in boy's clothes?" Jon's voice was every bit as high as Karyn's. Karyn thought that under the airheaded bewilderement the question seemed a bit forced. Could Jon be following my lead? She hoped that wasn't just wishful thinking.
"I'm sure there are some clothes in Karyn's dresser you could wear, Jenny." Sarah said, giving a name to Jon's new body. Showing no discomfort or shame, Jon walked over to Karyn's dresser, grabbing some clothes. When he reemerged from the bathroom he was clad in the same sort of revealing clothing Sarah wore, that was now part of Karyn's wardrobe. A pink baby tee, and blue short shorts. Apparently, they were close enough in size to share clothes.
"Like, what are we going to do tonight?" Jon asked in his bimboish new voice.
"I am sure we can find some cute guys at the mall. Stacey Gibson is waiting for us downstairs. We can go shopping and pick up a few while we're there." Sarah replied.
Karyn had no choice but to feign excitement and follow Sarah downstairs. She only hoped that she and Jon could keep up their new roles until they could get the stone back.