After opening the door, Dave saw an old man. Oddly, he was dressed in what appeared to be a bathrobe.
"Uh, can I help you?" Dave asked.
"Indeed you can. I believe you have something that belongs to me," the old man said. "It's a necklace, in fact."
"A necklace? My roommate Jake just bought a necklace today for his girlfriend Breanne." Dave paused for a moment. "Why did I tell you all that?" he muttered to himself.
"Because I willed you to. Now, take me to this Jake. I want my merchandise back."
"Certainly," Dave said, before leading the old man into the apartment, even though he'd rather slam the door in the guy's face and be done with him.
Back at the magic shop, Karyn stared into Jon's HD crystal ball. "Jon!" she shouted. "I think we may have a problem!"