Athena took the stone from Zoe, not realizing that it was actually The Gender Reversed Stone, and said "I wish Melissa Smith and Jessica Davis would become the ugliest girls in school." The stone glowed, granting the wish. But it didn't turn out the way they wanted.
"Good one," Zoe said. They turned and looked at the two girls, but were a little confused when they saw two nerdy boys in their place. The fat one (he must have weighed at least 300 pounds!) had the same blond hair as Melissa Smith, although messier, and the same color of clothing. But the clothes themselves looked totally nerdy. And the lanky one had the same brown hair as Jessica Davis, although shorter and greasier, and like the fat boy, he also had the same color of clothing, although the clothes themselves looked really dweeby. The lanky one also had a pimply face and thick glasses.
"Hey, what happened? Who are those two boys?" Athena asked. "What happened to Melissa and Jessica?"
Suddenly, there was another nerd who they knew was named Leonard Drullers. He ran towards the two new boys, yelling out their names in his very winded voice. "Hey! Milton, Josh! Wait up!"
The two Goth girls turned to one another, finally realizing what happened. The stone, for some reason, had turned Melissa Smith into a boy named Milton Smith, and had also turned Jessica Davis into a boy named Josh Davis. But why would the stone turn them into boys? Athena specifically wished for them to be the ugliest girls in school. Not the ugliest boys.