Just like before, Jon's wish wasn't granted the way he wanted it to be. Instead, his wish was changed to "I wish you were a Goth."
Suddenly, the mostly male Karyn began to change. But it wasn't his body that was changing, like what Jon had wished. Instead it was his clothes, which ended up being turned into a fishnet shirt, black leather pants, and black boots. Piercings appeared in his ears, nose, and lip, a spiked collar appeared around his neck, black lipstick appeared on his lips, black nail polish on his nails, and black eyeliner around his eyes. The only thing that changed about his body was his skin, which was now pale white.
"Wait. What the hell? This isn't what I wished!" Jon yelled.
The new gothic and mostly male Karyn looked down at himself in shock. "What the fuck did you do to me?" He heard Jon's wish (not the same one that was granted, but that didn't matter), so his mind didn't change with the rest of reality.