"I wish ..." Jon said, with a smile. "... that Karyn was naked and in my bedroom and desperately wanted to make love to me." Jon had been friends with Karyn since they were in grade school, but more recently, he had developed feelings for her that she obviously didn't have for him. But now, all of that would change ... or so he thought.
The stone glowed, but nothing seemed to happen.
That's because his wish was granted to his sister's friend Athena instead.
Athena was still fast asleep when Jon made his wish. But after his wish was granted, she was fully awake with her now-girlfriend (and naked) Karyn Black. They were both lesbians and had been dating in secret for months now. Athena and Karyn haven't even told their closest friends (Zoe and Jon, respectively) about their love for each other.
Karyn smiled as she sauntered towards her lover, not even realizing that reality was completely different.