What Zoe hadn't realized yet (or even Jon, Karyn, and Athena, for that matter) was that her second wish was granted to Karyn, since Karyn was the one nearest to the other stone at that exact moment. One might think that her wish would be a contradiction to the one she made earlier (the wish that changed Jon), but it wasn't. Zoe had previously wished to be the sexiest Goth girl at the school. But this time, she wished to be the sexiest Goth girl around. It seemed that the only way for the stone to grant that wish was to make it so that Karyn didn't go to that high school. That way, she was the sexiest Goth girl around, but Jon was still the sexiest Goth girl at the school.
"What's going on?" Zoe asked her former brother.
"What do you mean?" she asked back.