Karyn didn't notice anything different, and left the stone aside. But when she arrived at school later that morning, Alan, a friend of hers and Jon's, came right up to her and started to talk to her. He mentioned a date from last week, talked about a meeting with her parents that never happened, and finally kissed her--and he was a great kisser.
Karyn was glad that the wish had worked, but she knew she had to get the stone (or what she thought was the stone) back to Jon.
Only to stop when she saw Jon being kissed by Tim, another friend. She knew Jon wasn't gay and certainly not interested in Tim, but something had changed, and Jon didn't even seem to notice the difference....