Jon stammered. "Why don't y-- you... I don't think I can do it. It's too weird."
"But I'll do anything you ask!" exclaimed Jenna.
"Yeah, but... I know. I'll make this normal. Sit down, Jenna." She did, of course.
"Okay, I wish that the wishes that I make tonight after this one can be reversed by other wishes. I have to be careful about this."
"What are you going to do?" asked Jenna.
"If I want to magically make you be my girlfriend, I want it to be just like it is for everyone else. I can't keep thinking about all this magical stuff."
"I don't mind," said Jenna.
"But I do. I wish that at midnight tonight, reality will change so that Jenna is part of a family new to the area. I wish that neither of us will remember that we're really the same person split into two, but she'll still look and act like a female version of me. I wish that nobody will think this resemblance is very unusual. I wish that we'll meet tomorrow, find out we have a lot in common, and fall in love with each other. I wish that after we have sex, or after six months if we don't, we'll regain all our memories."
Now there was just some cleanup. Jon changed her hair and breasts to what they were before, and took away the obedience, but left her happy to be a girl. Then he made her fall asleep, and he went to sleep too.
Some time after Jon went to sleep, midnight came.
The next day, Jon woke up, and checked on his stone. He had used it the other night... no, he didn't. At least he didn't remember using it.
At school, he met a new girl. Oddly, the girl looked almost exactly like him, except for longer hair and a female face and body. It was a little unusual, but no big deal, nothing to be worried about.
"Hi!" she said. "My name's Jenna. I just heard you say your favorite food is mushroom pizza. It's a strange coincidence, but so is mine...."
