(Originally written by: LGV)
"N-no, of course not! I would never do something so creepy to my friends" Caleb said.
"Tsk-tsk. You know, Caleb, you shouldn't lie to a being that knows everything about you. You've stolen a pair of panties from literally everyone here, you little pervert."
The girls, stabbed by betrayal, looked at him with pure disgust. They knew that he was attracted to a few of them, but to do something so outrageous? They were furious.
"O-okay! I'm sorry!" he apologized. "I'm a guy, what can you expect? Plus, it's not like I did anything to you girls directly, right?"
His apologies fell on deaf ears. They were having none of it.
"Oh Caleb, if you had been this honest before, things could have gone much smoother for you. The girls would still be upset with you, of course, but you wouldn't have to receive a punishment. Now then, I think its only fair that one of the girls get revenge. So, here's your dare: you must lick Marla's feet clean!"
"Are you serious? Not Marla! She plays literally every sport. Her feet must be awful..."
"Those are the terms. Either accept them or receive further punishment."