Jon had turned into a girl. At least it looked like it.
"Jon, are you a girl?" she asked.
The new girl, who was still wearing jeans and a shirt, although with heels that still didn't raise her height to that of Jon as he was before, replied "Uhh, yes I am, Karyn. You're calling me Jon instead of Josephine, and that's a guy's name. Are you really trying to hint that I'm not really a girl? That can't possibly be true."
"You are a girl," said Karyn. "I wasn't sure what was going to happen and then it occurred to me that my wish should make guys wear bikinis. But you're not."
"Guys wearing bikinis?"
"I didn't change you," said Karyn. "I changed the poster in your room."
"Oh, really?" replied Josephine. She got up from the couch and walked towards her room. "This I've got to see." Karyn followed her and they entered the room. It was a perfectly normal teenage girl's room. Josephine looked around and spotted the poster. She pointed at it. "You mean that poster? I don't see any bikini."
"I don't get it. No, wait a minute, I do. If I wish for the poster to show a guy and it leaves the bikini on, it has to make two changes. First of all it has to be normal for guys to wear bikinis. Second it has to be normal for you to have a poster of a guy no matter what he's wearing, so you're a girl or gay. It's simpler to change the poster to a normal guy and only have to do one of those."
"So let me get this straight, you're saying I'm not a girl? So I am a guy?"
"Uh, heh heh. To tell the truth..." She looked down and said "Yes you are."
"But I've always been a girl! I joined the Girl Scouts, I have a boyfriend... you and I watch yaoi together... Seriously?"
"Yes."
"So how long does it last before I lose my breasts and all that?"
"How long does it last?"
"Yeah... how long does it last. We just finished proving that wishes aren't permanent if you add 'for only five minutes' or something to them."
"Oh, my god. I forgot that. I just wished that that and other posters would show men. I didn't put a time limit on it...."
