Jon realized that having lots of people come to the magic shower could be a problem, and made another whispered wish. "I wish that the magic shower would stop working until I wish it back".
Immediately the flow of water from the shower head began to slow down, and then stop.
"I should never have said that!" yelled Jeff. "Something happened... I said I wanted to know what it was like and then it happened. Some evil force must have heard me and unlocked the shower..."
"Jeff, calm down," said Jon.
"I won't calm down! You're used to it! How can I get used to it like you?"
Which wasn't quite right. Jon didn't really have the effects for ten years--it was a recent wish. But he was calmer than Jeff, if only because he had some hope that it could be reversed and he knew that even ignoring that, he could use wishes to help a little.
"Just think 'I want to get used to it'," said Jon.
In the meantime, Jon turned aside and muttered a wish to himself. "I wish that once Jeff thinks that, he and everyone else who knows about it or finds out about it will get used to him being that way."
"I can't do it!" said Jeff.
"Just try. For a second..."
"All right. I guess I need to get used to it... hm? Oh, you're right, Jon. I guess I just needed to calm down and realize that I had to live with it."
Jon turned back and found himself looking at Alan's butt in a mirror. Just like a few minutes ago, he had to admit Alan wasn't bad-looking, for a guy... was he getting attracted to guys just because he had a pussy?
Alan looked back at Jon and Jon realized it was a similar sort of look. But then Alan looked at Jeff.
Should Jon try to date guys, he wondered? He was, after all, supposed to have dated Alan before in the new history. It couldn't hurt, after all...
"So, Jeff," said Alan, "you're feeling okay?"
"Sure," replied Jeff. "I said I wanted to learn what it is to be like this and date both sexes, and I guess I can find out. Alan, would you like to go out with me?"
Jon's wish was working--they were used to Jeff being that way, used to it enough that they were willing to date. But that wasn't really in Jon's plans, now that he realized he found guys a little bit attractive. He wanted to try dating guys too. "Wait a minute," said Jon. "Alan, would you like to go out with me? I mean, it isn't the first time..."
Alan looked between the two and said "I never expected I'd have to pick between two guys with pussies. I'd never expected there'd even be more than one. But the answer is 'yes'. The one I'd like to go out with is..."