Patty smiled the smile of the spider to the fly, "first, I wish i knew more about you." Suddenly, she knew Joan's cup size. "Karyn, please be reasonable. If you aren't, you'll only make it worse for your friend. I wish that I knew a basic background of Joan's life."
Karyn couldn't find a way around that wish, so she let Patty know about the rock and their wishes, along with half of Jon's childhood.
"Thank you Karyn. I should have known it was your boyfriend you were protecting. Now, for your punishment, Jon. First, I wish..."