Once they were all in Penny's car Allison began to explain.
"Ok, bear with me, some of this will sound impossible, but strangely enough it sort of makes sense." Allison looked at the two to be sure that they were listening before continuing.
"All right, first off, Penny, do you remember having a conversation with me by the water cooler this morning?" Allison wasn't sure that Penny would, but if she did then it would help in the explanation.
"Of course, we talked about how annoyed I was with how Mr. Johnson had been treating me, how Mikey was sick, and how Zoe and I got in an argument about her dress she was wearing." Penny then frowned slightly. "Huh, now that I think about it more though, that argument was just silly. I don't see anything wrong with dress she wanted to wear. It was really cute actually, you know, the black parachute dress with a slit in the tummy section? I should get myself one of those for work sometime, but red, the boys would love me in red."
"Penny! We're talking about our problem, remember?"
Penny blushed "Sorry, keep going Ali."
Allison shifted positions a few times before continuing. She was almost squirming a little. "Sorry, I can't seem to get comfortable for some reason. Is it hot in here?" Both Penny and Jenna shook their heads. Shrugging Allison continued, "Anyway, do you remember telling me something you wished about Zoe, Penny?"
"Actually, yeah, now that you mention it. I wished I would be able to understand her better or something like that."
"Right!" Allison said smiling. "Well, I too made a wish by the water cooler this morning when I was talking to Jenna."
"Wait! You're that Allison?" Jenna asked incredulously.
"Oh good, you remember me! Although, I suppose it makes sense because I somehow remembered Peter." Allison could only smile as the pieces of the puzzle started to fall into place for Jenna.
"Hold on! You wished you had a body like mine!" Jenna exclaimed before she took in the last of Allison's statement. "Why do you keep bringing up this Peter guy?"
"Because," Allison began, "this morning, Penny used to be Peter!"
"What?!" both Jenna and Penny chimed in unison.
"No, really. I know it's absurd, I didn't believe it at first either. Before I changed into your sister I had a long talk with Penny. In which, she insisted that she used to be a man named Peter Parker. A man that only the two of us at the time seemed to remember."
"Ali, I said nothing of the sort. You came in just after Jenna went to see Mr. Johnson. We talked about all sorts of things but we didn't talk about anything as strange as that."
"Well of course that's what you remember, Penny." Allison stated. "Your memory changed the moment I became your sister. You became just like everyone else, thinking things had always been this way." Allison began to squirm again and unbuttoned her blouse down to just below her bra.
"I think you might be on to something there Allison." Jenna chimed in. "I mean, it sure explains you, but I still have a hard time believing your claim about Penny. I have memories and everything of growing up with her."
"Well I find it all rather hard to believe, I've know you both all my life. We've always been sisters and I can't imagine it any other way." Penny voiced, obviously doubting the whole thing.
"And there you have it, I think the reason why Jenna and I can remember how I used to be is because we both heard my wish. The same applies to me and Penny before my wish was granted. We could both remember Peter. But when my wish went into effect, Penny hadn't heard it and so her memories were changed to match the new reality created by me becoming your sister."
"Wow, this is all so amazing! What do you think granted the wishes and why'd they take so long to take effect?" Jenna asked.
"I don't know, that's a good question. One which I have no ideas on what the answer may be." Allison mused about it some before squirming some more in her seat. It was like some pressure was building up inside of her, almost as if she was... horny?
"You OK, Ali?" Penny asked her sister showing some concern at Allison's apparent unease.
"I don't know, it's like ever since we left the office I've felt something building inside of me. I think... I think it's me getting horny, but it doesn't make any sense." Allison's nipples were visible through her blouse now. They stuck out like cherries on top of an ice cream sundae. Very carefully she touched one of them... big mistake. Just that one slight touch had sent fire tingling up and down her body. "Oooh!" A mildly sensual moan escaped her lips. Her vagina was starting to get wet.
"What the hell, Allison, do you need a room?" Jenna jokingly asked.
"God I might! Sorry girls, I don't know what's come over me. It's so strong though, uhhnn, I've got to take care of it now!" Allison was now groping her breast with one hand and had her other underneath her skirt, rubbing her pussy through her silk panty.
"Hold on, we're almost there and then you can go in my bedroom and do it." Penny told her. She looked over at Jenna and didn't have to say a word, from the look in her eyes they were both thinking the same thing. More strange changes were happening.
